Questions to Ask When Vetting a Legal Specialist

Not sure how to tell a genuine specialist from someone who just says they handle 'all types of law'? Here's a plain-English list of vetting questions.

Anyone can put 'specialist' in their advertising. Vetting means asking a few pointed questions that separate genuine depth of experience from a broad general practice wearing a narrower label.

Ask about caseload composition, specifically

'What percentage of your current cases are [your practice area]?' A genuine specialist typically answers with a high number and specifics. A generalist often gives a vaguer, more general answer.

Ask about outcomes in similar situations, generally

Without asking for guarantees (which no honest attorney will give), ask what a realistic range of outcomes looks like for situations like yours, based on their experience. Specificity here is a good sign; vagueness is a caution flag.

Ask who will actually work on your case

In some practices, a well-known specialist signs on new clients but hands day-to-day work to less experienced associates. Ask directly who you'll be working with most of the time.

Ask what makes your situation different from a typical case in their practice

A genuine specialist can usually articulate what's unusual or noteworthy about your specific facts — because they've seen enough similar cases to recognize what stands out. A vague, one-size-fits-all answer is worth noticing.

Frequently asked

Helpful resources for your next step

Vetting worksheets, plus estate-planning references if that's the specialist you're comparing. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases — at no additional cost to you.

Related reading